Ranking the Final Fantasy Series: From Worst to Best

Mar
17

Ranking the Final Fantasy Series: From Worst to Best

To celebrate the North American release of Final Fantasy Type-0 HD, I thought that there was no better time to take a look back at the entire Final Fantasy series.  Square’s seminal RPG series has seen it’s ups and downs, but just how much variance is there between each title?

First, some rules.  In this particular list, I’m only going to be ranking the numbered Final Fantasy games.  That means no spinoffs such as Final Fantasy Tactics or Mystic Quest.    I also will not be looking at any direct sequels, such as Final Fantasy X-2 or Final Fantasy XIII-2.  Finally, I will be excluding the MMORPG’s from this list.  They’re a different style of game from traditional Final Fantasy, and I’ve never been interested in any sort of MMO, and as such I have never played either of the FF MMOs and therefore cannot rank them.

Excluding Final Fantasy XI and Final Fantasy XIV, this leaves 12 mainline games to rank, and I’ll be going from what I feel is the worst game to what I feel is the best.  I’m trying to stay as objective as a personal opinion can be.  While normally I would rank the games differently based on nostalgia and personal emotions, I’m trying my best to rank the games based on how good they are as actual games, independent of whatever memories I may have for each title.

Final Fantasy II

While filled with innovative ideas, Final Fantasy II had too much ambition and not enough ability.

Final Fantasy II introduced two big changes from it’s predecessor: A brand new battle system and an actual cast of characters.  These characters, while primitive by today’s standards, were a great leap forward for the genre as they threw themselves around the screen and attempted to tell a story.  Final Fantasy II told the story of a group of orphans leading a resistance against a powerful, evil empire and it never aspired to be anything it wasn’t.  Added to this was a revolving cast of characters – the fourth character slot would be replaced by someone new in each chapter – that each had a distinct personality and gave the game world the flavour and variety that was missing from other RPGs of the time.

Unfortunately, the battle system didn’t fare as well as the characters.  The core concept is that characters gain stats as they use them.  For example, taking physical damage will raise a character’s HP and defense, while dealing damage will raise either physical or magical attack power depending on the type of attack used.  It’s an interesting system, for sure, but is easily broken and often results in excessive grinding and damaging your own characters since their stats won’t grow enough just from enemy encounters.  This battle system may be less than ideal, but it doesn’t ruin the game.

What ruins Final Fantasy II is a series of baffling design decisions that seem designed more to annoy the player than to entertain them.  One example of this is the dungeon design.  Most of the sprawling, labyrinthine dungeons featured a plethora of doors that the player can open and explore.  Yet 90% of these doors contained empty rooms, and every time the player went through a door they would be teleported to the middle of the room, and every step toward the exit would trigger a “random” encounter.

Adding to this was the illusion of freedom in the overworld.  Backtracking to and from locations was a frequent occurrence, and any attempt to stray from the beaten path would end in brutal defeat.  Stepping even one tile too far would allow monstrously powerful enemies to attack, ensuring that the player stays focused in the most frustrating way possible.  While I’m not sure I’d consider any numbered game in the series to be a “bad game”, Final Fantasy II certainly comes the closest.

Final Fantasy VIII

Following up Final Fantasy VII was no easy task, and I’m certainly not going to directly compare the two.  Despite being subsequent entries in the same series, they are both very different from one another and seek to do different things.  However, while I felt that Final Fantasy VII accomplished it’s goal magnificently, I felt that VIII missed it’s mark.

Final Fantasy VIII suffers from two main problems: Story and systems.  We’ll start with the story.  At it’s heart, Final Fantasy VIII is a love story, and the main story arc is about the growing affections between Squall and Rinoa.  It’s an interesting concept, but it just doesn’t work.  Squall and Rinoa have very little chemistry together which makes everything between them come off as contrived and forced.  They’re together only because the game says they should be, not because they have any believable reason to be.  Unfortunately, the rest of the cast is just as weak, going from forgettable and inconsequential to just plain annoying, with the only bright spot being Seifer. The plotline itself is no better, presenting a few interesting scenarios but utterly wasting them by throwing in some of the worst twists ever seen in a story.  You know exactly what I’m talking about here.

Moving on, we have the game’s systems, primarily the battle system and junctioning system.  It’s an interesting idea, but is ultimately too inconsistent.  It’s a complex system that the game never fully explains.  If you don’t fully understand it, the game becomes a slog of endless summons and slow battles.  Once you do understand it, the game breaks completely to the point where battles become wholly unnecessary and you’re left wondering why they even bothered to have battles in the first place.

Despite it’s well realized, interesting world and one of the best minigames in gaming history, Final Fantasy VIII‘s core components are just too flawed to allow me to rank it any higher.

Final Fantasy XIII

Final Fantasy XIII is the game that everyone loves to hate, and it almost seems too easy ranking it near the bottom of the list.  I really wanted to like it, but for every enjoyable piece it presented, there were another two frustrating moments waiting just behind it.

The battle system was a brilliant, being fast paced and cinematic while maintaining a classic Final Fantasy feel.  Unfortunately, the battle system only truly worked when it was used with a full party, and the game decided to let you go through two thirds of the game using only 2 characters.  The battle was considerably less exciting and versatile when played like this, and it didn’t even fully unlock itself until you were well over a dozen hours into the adventure.

Outside of battle didn’t fare much better, with the rest of the game being accurately described by the word “straight”.  JRPG’s are no strangers to linearity and illusion of choice, but Final Fantasy XIII took this to the extreme.  The first 75% of the game is essentially one long hallway, with very, very few occasions to tread off the beatn path or even do anything other than “run forward, battle, run forward some more”.  This extreme linearity permeated every aspect of the game – not even the levelling system was safe.  It looked like you had choice, sure, with the branching paths of the Crystarium, but the game very tightly controlled how much and how often you levelled, locking away large swaths of the Crystarium and giving you just enough points to unlock the available skills in the exact order the game wanted you to.

This could, perhaps, all be forgiven if the story and world of Final Fantasy XIII engulfed me enough.  But once again the game falls well short of its potential.  It presents an interesting setting and backdrop, only to do absolutely nothing with it and instead introducing jargon and confusing lingo as an illusion for depth.

Final Fantasy III

If I’m being completely honest here, Final Fantasy III is the game I’ve played the least of.  This is probably because it took so long to come to the west (we didn’t get an official release until 2006).  From what I did play I saw that it was a very mechanics heavy game, and introduced the classic job system.  There’s a lot of depth to the system, especially compared to other it’s contemporaries.

Final Fantasy III isn’t a bad game by any means, it’s just not as interesting as the games that came after it.

Final Fantasy

The original that started it all, Final Fantasy was an ambitious game for it’s day.  Loaded with customization that Dragon Quest lacked, and attempting to tell a much grander story, Final Fantasy showed that the series’ cinematic tendencies can be traced back to the very beginning.  The true brilliance, though, is that Final Fantasy treads a perfect line between simplicity and complexity.  It offers enough complexity to keep the player engaged and moving forward, but not enough to have them bogged down in confusing systems and convoluted stories.

Final Fantasy XII

Not being a person who plays MMOs, Final Fantasy XII is probably the closest I’m going to get to experiencing what they are like.  Clearly taking cues from it’s multiplayer focused predecessor, Final Fantasy XII eschews the traditonal turn-based battle system and instead introduced a real-time system that was like an MMO-lite.  It also reintroduced us to the world of Ivalice and a story that had ambitions beyond the usual fare of young heroes saving the world.

This ambition is exactly what places Final Fantasy XII so high on the list – It’s focus on a political story and the subsequent clash of nations is a refreshing change and really helps give the game an identity unlike any other game in the series.  Additionally, It has more of focus on world building than the other games in the series, slowly introducing us to the various races and factions that make up Ivalice and making it’s main city of Rabanastre not just a lifeless backdrop, but a place that actually feels alive.

The only thing preventing Final Fantasy XII from being higher on the list are results of it’s turbulent development cycle.  The game switched directors partway through development and as a result there are some pretty radical shifts in tone between parts of the game that were clearly created by different people.  This results in a story that often meanders for long periods of time while going nowhere as well as two main characters that are nowhere near as interesting as the cast supporting them.

I can’t help but feel that, if the game were completed following Matsuno’s original vision, that Final Fantasy XII would be near the top of the list, but I guess there’s no way to know for sure.

Final Fantasy V

Final Fantasy V isn’t a game from which many ideas originated, but it is a game in which those ideas were perfected.  The legendary Final Fantasy job system is perfected in this entry, and is proof that an RPG can focus entirely around one central system if that system is done as well as it was here.

Final Fantasy IV

Looking back, Final Fantasy IV is filled to the brim with cliches and genre tropes – which is really a testament to it’s quality. Not so much that it managed to be a great despite its adherence to these tropes, but because it was instrumental in establishing them in the first place.

Final Fantasy IV introduced the Active Time Battle – the most used system in the series to date – and a cast that attempted to be more than cardboard cutouts. Whether it was the new technology or Square’s growing talent, Final Fantasy IV rethought what an RPG could be.

If I were ranking the series more personally, FF4 would take the #1 spot. It was, after all, the game that introduced me to the series and made me fall in love with RPGs. Instead, it’s outranked by a few later entries because despite all the leap forwards, Final Fantasy IV just isn’t quite refined enough and is still a little rough around the edges.

Final Fantasy X

A new platform always means big jumps for the series, and Final Fantasy X was no different. For the first time in the series’ history we got fully voiced characters and full 3D environments, bringing the story to life.

There were some changes – no world map and the battle system dropped the “Active Time” portion, but they were sacrifices I was more than willing to make. Finally, the entire cast could participate in battles, and outside they managed to interact in more ways than ever before. At it’s heart, Final Fantasy X is more of a character drama, and it’s the best one Square has ever produced.

Final Fantasy IX

After two modern-styled games that took the world by storm, Final Fantasy IX was considered a throwback to the classic days of the franchise.  It went back to the traditional fantasy designs that originally made the series famous and served as a warm, nostalgic trip for longtime fans.  Luckily, IX wasn’t a one-trick pony that relied solely on it’s nostalgic vibe to enthral players.  It was every bit as good as the older games and was a great way to combine old-school sensibilities with new-age technology, as well as being Sakaguchi’s send-off to the series.

What really made Final Fantasy IX unique was it’s atmosphere: The entire game played out almost like a fairy tale.  Characters were funny and quirky and the story was paced perfectly, ebbing and flowing throughout the course of the game to hold the player’s interest.  Even the music, one of Uematsu’s best scores, gave off a fairy tale vibe and gave the game more a “magical fantasy” theme than any Final Fantasy before (or after).  But the best part was how well the characters meshed together, becoming realistic representations of friends despite their cartoonish appearances.

If there’s one criticism I have of the game, it’s that the battle system is so damn slow.  The pace and frequency of combat isn’t a problem, but the default speed for the ATB is excruciatingly slow.

Final Fantasy VII

Is there really much I can say about Final Fantasy VII? You know good and well what this game is. Even calling it a “game” is a downplaying it a bit. Final Fantasy VII is a phenomenon, an obsession. I’ve yet to meet a Final Fantasy fan who hasn’t played it.

If I’m being honest, the only real negative point I can give to Final Fantasy VII is that it has an almost laughably poor translation – but that’s not really the fault of the original creators.

Final Fantasy VI

Final Fantasy VI is everything a Final Fantasy should be.  From the moment the game begins with the march through the snow, you know you’re in for something special.  Final Fantasy VI is hardly the most innovative game in the series; As the last of the SNES trilogy it’s more concerned with perfection than innovation.  It took the best parts of every previous game and wrapped them together in a package that took the series to new heights.

Nowhere is this more apparent than in the game’s story.  For the first time the characters became more than sprites on a screen – they became actual, living characters.  Videogame storylines had never been more engaging or emotional, nor any villain more terrifying.  It’s a testament to the strengths of FF6 that even 20 years after it’s release it’s still held as a beacon of videogame storytelling.

Final Fantasy VI may have been the last 2D game in the series, but it certainly ended with a bang and became the pinnacle of the entire genre.

——–

There you have it, my ranking of Final Fantasy games.  I’m sure your own personal ranking will be vastly different from what I have above, so leave a comment and let me know how you would rank them.  Or spread this around Twitter and tell everyone how wrong I am.

About Justin Arnott

Justin is the Founder of Controller Crusade and has played video games for as long as he can remember. He loves all games but there's an extra special place in his heart for anything created by Nintendo. He's also a big retro gamer and is deeply interested in video game history—so there's that. You can contact him via email at jarnott@controllercrusade.com or via Twitter @sirultimos

6 comments

  • DukeKataron
    Apr 25, 2015 @ 20:24 pm

    I agree with most of this list. I’ve played every Final Fantasy game from start to finish, including the spinoffs and weird sequels.

    To those arguing that Final Fantasy 8 is better than 13, I would disagree. Neither are good games, but at least 13 kept me interested. 8 ultimately fell through on everything that a game should have. The characters were uninspired and boring, their motives confusing at best. The story was a jumble of weird ideas that don’t fit well together at all. The twists and turns were just…ugh. Moon monsters, amnesia, a cast of characters who knew each other as children and somehow found each other again but oh wait point two was amnesia so they don’t remember.

    And while 13 wasn’t much better storywise, at least it had the mechanics down. The most interesting part of 8 was the GF system. The junctioning was, as Justin says, either confusing or gamebreaking. The magic system was idiotic, forcing you to either conserve your magic for junctioning or constantly finding draw points or convenient enemies. To do well, you had to spend ages in battles endlessly drawing magic from your foes. There is nothing remotely fun about that. The weapon upgrade system was bad as well, and their attempting to play off of the success of FF7’s limit breaks fell through entirely. The way everything levelled up with you was interesting, but didn’t make much sense for a Final Fantasy world. The enemies you walked over in the beginning of the game suddenly having access to top tier magic spells because you got stronger? All right…

    I’ve played FF8 from start to finish more than once. I’ve given it a fair chance. It’s just…It’s not a good game.

    That said, it has probably the best soundtrack from any Final Fantasy game ever, and the card game system was a blast. Unfortunately, that can’t save a game.

    Reply
    • DnaAngel
      Jan 6, 2016 @ 5:47 am

      I agree. FF8 was just bad all around. I too gave it more than enough chances, but just couldn’t stomach it long enough. I too have played all the Final Fantasy’s from start to finish(except Type-0) more than a few times, including both MMO’s. FF9 for me was my all time favorite, just something about it really moved me, even being just one of 2 video games to ever make me cry like a baby at the end. FF7 was good, but I never creamed over it like everyone else seems to. idk, it just never really did all that much for me, still a solid 7/10 game though. 6 was great, 12 was great, X/X-2 were OK, I actually liked X-2 better haha. The rest were good, but forgettable.

      Word has it SE is remastering FF9 and will be releasing it to Steam/PC in the next year or two. Can’t wait!!

      Reply
  • Loose cannon
    Mar 17, 2015 @ 17:17 pm

    We all disagree about FF games, its inevitable, but the fact remains almost all FF were good with the exception of FFXIII. To me it was FFVIII the best of them all although FFVII and FFXI also were good. I think the writer missed the mark lol. FFVIII was a more elegant, action oriented, better story line than FFVII ever was and replay ability values for VIII its outstanding. No FF series ever make me want to play it again except for ff7 and ff8. 8 to me was and still is the best of them all, takes a little understanding at the begining but once u know the draw system its all about combos.

    Reply
  • Jack
    Mar 17, 2015 @ 15:02 pm

    This is just an opinion piece and should not be taken as fact in anyway.

    Reply
  • Ed.
    Mar 17, 2015 @ 11:42 am

    Completely agree with Tjaffrey.

    There’s NO way that 8 is worse than 13. Bottom line.

    Reply
  • Tjaffrey
    Mar 17, 2015 @ 11:26 am

    Ranking FF VIII lower than XIII????? stopped reading right after i saw that.
    At least VIII felt like a final fantasy, where XIII didn’t even feel like a FF to me. More like a spin-off
    The story of FF VIII felt really compeling to me, in contrary to XIII which i played a while ago and don’t even remember what it was about.
    It had no impact on me.

    Reply

Leave a comment

Sponsored

Around the Web